When I first discovered Mumsnet I was a naive first time mum. I’d gone through horrendous depression in pregnancy that had knocked my confidence and made me into a very timid, nervous, hesitant person. I was alienated from my friends, alone in the house with the baby all day, scared and desperately depressed.
I remember my first tentative post on Mumsnet – and then my shock when people actually replied! I was not treated like some brain-dead depressive, no-one said that my job of looking after my baby was worthless. Here was a place where I could have an opinion, a point of view, and that opinion mattered! I was taken seriously!
I owe Mumsnet a debt of gratitude for replacing my confidence, for helping me to get back on my feet and think of myself as a worthwhile person after all who has something to say. Not only that but I found myself in a position to help others – to help those who found breastfeeding hard, to help those who were also depressed in their pregnancies but afraid to speak out. I loved seeking advice and I loved giving it.
That was in 2001. Since then Mumsnet has undergone changes. Some I disagreed with and some I thought were for the better, but I never thought the spirit of Mumsnet had changed. Secret Santa was thought up a few years ago to help those who had been having bad years. The community of Mumsnet still got together to help fellow Mumsnetters in need – I have been helped countless times by Mumsnetters who didn’t know me, but just wanted to do something to help. I can’t tell you how good that feels!
For me, Mumsnet became something of an escapism from everyday life. In life I was judged for being a mother, for choosing to stay at home, for having a Northern accent, for coming from Oldham, for the way I looked, the clothes I wore etc etc. But on Mumsnet I was judged only for the opinions I had. I loved to debate, to research, to discover things I didn’t know through Mumsnet. If I had a bad day, I knew I could start a thread about it on Mumsnet and have sympathy. If I had a problem with my mother, I knew I only had to mention her on Mumsnet and there would be people familiar with the background who would give me support. I could laugh on Mumsnet and be laughed at, I could divulge the most embarrassing medical conditions and get sound advice. What more could you ask from a site?
I felt so comfortable that I went to a few meet-ups. Just local ones at first, then I was blackmailed by Custy into going to my first ever London one. I’ve now been to two and enjoyed them thoroughly. I loved putting faces to names and seeing if they were the same as on Mumsnet. I made new friends.
But then the disagreements became more personal. I can honestly say, hand on heart, that I do not have an MSN list of Mumsnetters. I have 2 Mumsnetters on my facebook (not including custy). I generally say everything I want to on Mumsnet. This has caused some ill feeling amongst those who feel I have disagreed with them too strongly, or just disagreed with them for the hell of it. For whatever reason, I found that I had made enemies. I also discovered that custy had made many more (!) and that those people were also targeting me by association.
Narniagate happened. A Mumsnetter who had taken a real dislike to me because I asked her on Mumsnet to stop making lesbian type comments on every thread she posted on. She discovered that you could comment on threads that had been deleted by googling them and they wouldn’t appear in active convos. She told a few others about it, swore them to secrecy and the rule was to say 3 bitchy things about a fellow mumsnetter. I was her first target. I was really upset when I found out. Not only had she bitched about me behind my back but encouraged others to do the same!
I took a sabbatical, thought it would all be fresh and new when I got back. And for a while it was, it became my escapism again. But now all this Mouldygate has blown up and I admit, it really got to me.
Sure, as others have said, there are sites that are invite only, you get them on facebook. But I know those sites are out there. There’s an ante-natal one which you obv wouldn’t join unless you were expecting, but if you felt you fitted the criteria you could ask for membership. They are not secret. This one was. Secret invites sent out, people discussed and then vetoed. I found out that those people I had had those disagreements with, were part of it. I had the sick feeling I had when I found out about Narniagate.
A fair criticism has been thrown at us saying that it’s not all about us. Of course it isn’t. I feel heartened to an extent that others have also been hurt, because it’s incredibly isolating when it’s just you. I’ve had the snidey comments on threads around Mumsnet and know all too well that paranoid feeling of ‘Is it just me or they are actually having a go at every thing I say?’ And of course you can’t ask anyone else because then you are accused of having no sense of humour and suffering from paranoia.
But this time real life has spilled into my little escape route. Mumsnet is no longer a happy place for me to be. It’s become a very confrontational place.
People forget that we are human. I am a mum. I have an 8 year old daughter and a 4 year son. I have relationship problems on and off, I worry about my kids, I worry that I’m not a good enough mother, that I’ve made all the wrong choices in life. I worry about the bills and our jobs and what to have for tea. I’m not some nameless entity on an internet site. And for me this Mouldygate is the equivalent of having a secret gang of mums who whisper outside the school gates. You can’t prove that they are whispering about you, but every now and then they look your way and snigger. After a while that’s going to affect you. And that is how this has affected me.
I’m sorry the members cannot understand that. I understand and sympathise with why some are members. A few have been kind enough to contact me and let me know why they are members – I appreciate their honesty. There is a need for a private site where personal things can be discussed with people who know you. These sites exist. But the whispering that has gone on here, the denials and lies, the leaks of hurtful information – all of that is more about the playground whispering than anything else.
I’d hate to leave Mumsnet. But I think perhaps it has spilled over too much into real life. It’s making me feel worse about myself than ever before. I could never go on a meet-up now knowing that there are people who detest me, who would whisper about me, avoid me. That’s not how I live in real life and it’s not how I want to be on the internet either. I am no different in real life to my online persona. In real life if that happened I would move away, I would not allow it to continue. So I’m thinking that is what I should do here.







